Maccy vs Paste: Which Mac Clipboard Manager Fits You?
Maccy vs Paste: Which Mac Clipboard Manager Fits You?
Quick answer: Choose Maccy if you want a fast, keyboard-first, free and open-source clipboard history that stays on your Mac. Choose Paste if you want iCloud sync to iPhone and iPad, visual previews, shared pinboards, and you’re happy to pay a subscription (or a one-time lifetime fee) for that polish.
Both apps solve the same core problem: macOS remembers only one thing at a time, and you copy dozens. They disagree on almost everything else.
What happened to “Paste 3”?
If you searched for “Paste 3,” you were probably looking at an older review. Paste 3 is a legacy major version. The Mac App Store listing I checked while writing this showed Paste at version 6, redesigned for Apple’s Liquid Glass look. So this article compares Maccy App against current Paste, not version 3. If you’re still on an old build, most of the differences below apply even more strongly: Paste has been a subscription product since its 2.x days, and its feature set has grown a lot since.
Maccy vs Paste at a glance
| Factor | Maccy | Paste |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Free (open source). A paid Mac App Store build also exists. | Subscription or lifetime. US App Store listing: $3.99/month, $29.99/year, $89.99 lifetime (Mac + iOS). Free trial available. |
| Platforms | macOS only | Mac, iPhone, iPad |
| Sync | None. History stays local. | iCloud sync of history and pinboards |
| Interface | Compact, searchable list that opens at your cursor or menu bar | Large visual previews in a full-width shelf |
| Search | Fuzzy by default; exact, regex and mixed modes available | Search by content, with filters for type and source app |
| Organization | Pinned items | Pinboards, including shared pinboards for collaboration |
| Automation | Keyboard shortcuts | Siri Shortcuts support |
| Source code | Public on GitHub | Closed source |
| Accounts | None | Uses your Apple ID / iCloud |
Paste details above come from the developer’s App Store listing. Prices vary by region and can change, so check the listing before you buy.
Which one is cheaper over time?
Maccy Mac wins on cost, with a caveat. The open-source build costs nothing and you can install it with Homebrew (brew install maccy) or from GitHub. Paying for the App Store version is optional support for the developer.
Paste’s math depends on how long you’ll use it. At the listed prices, the annual plan reaches the lifetime price in a bit over three years ($29.99 × 3 = $89.97). If you know you’ll use Paste for years and want iOS too, lifetime is the better deal. If you’re unsure, the free trial is the right place to find out. And if you only ever need clipboard history on one Mac, you’re paying for sync and design you may not use.
Where Paste is genuinely better
It would be dishonest to pretend Maccy Clipboard wins everywhere. Paste is stronger in several areas that matter to real people:
- Cross-device clipboard. Paste syncs through iCloud and has iPhone and iPad apps. Maccy has nothing comparable. If you copy on your phone and paste on your Mac daily, this alone decides it.
- Visual browsing. Large previews make images, colors, and formatted snippets easy to recognize at a glance. Maccy’s list is faster to scan for text but plainer for visual material.
- Pinboards and sharing. Paste lets you organize clips into pinboards and share them with collaborators. Maccy’s pins are a flat list.
- Siri Shortcuts. If you build automations around your clipboard, Paste offers hooks Maccy doesn’t.
- Multi-item paste. Paste advertises pasting several items in a chosen order, which is handy for assembling forms or documents.
Where Maccy is genuinely better
- Speed and footprint. Maccy is small and keyboard-driven. The default shortcut is Shift+Cmd+C; type to search, press Return, and the item is pasted. There’s no shelf to navigate.
- Price and openness. It’s free, and you can read the source. For people who care about what runs on their machine, that matters.
- No account, no sync service. History lives on your Mac. There’s no cloud copy to think about, which simplifies the privacy picture.
- Power search. Beyond default fuzzy matching, Maccy can search by exact text or regular expressions (Settings → Advanced). That’s useful when your history holds hundreds of similar snippets, like log lines or URLs.
- Simplicity. Fewer features means fewer settings to maintain.
How do they handle privacy and sensitive copies?
This is where clipboard managers deserve scrutiny, because they quietly record everything you copy, including passwords and tokens.
Maccy stores history locally. You can exclude specific apps under Settings → Ignore, and it respects the convention password managers use to flag concealed clipboard content. Since there’s no sync, nothing leaves your Mac.
Paste says data is stored securely on your device and in your private iCloud account, and it supports rules to exclude specific apps from capture. That’s a sensible design, but it means your clipboard history exists in iCloud too. Whether that’s acceptable depends on your threat model.
With either app, exclude your password manager and your terminal if you routinely copy secrets, and clear history after sensitive work.
Which should you choose?
Skip the feature checklist and ask which of these sounds like you:
- “I live on my Mac and mostly copy text and code.” Maccy. You’ll get everything you need, for free.
- “I copy between my phone and my Mac all day.” Paste. Maccy can’t do this.
- “I work with images, design assets, or mixed media.” Try Paste first. The visual previews earn their keep.
- “I don’t trust cloud sync with my clipboard.” Maccy.
- “I hate subscriptions.” Maccy, or Paste’s lifetime option if you need its features.
- “I want to collaborate on shared snippets with a team.” Paste, thanks to shared pinboards.
You can also run both for a week. Neither locks you in, and your habits will tell you quickly whether you reach for a rich shelf or a fast search box.
Switching from Paste to Maccy
Your Paste history won’t transfer, so expect to start fresh. The practical steps are:
- Install Maccy via Homebrew or GitHub, or from the Mac App Store.
- Open Settings and set your preferred shortcut and history size.
- Add apps you want ignored under Ignore.
- Pin the snippets you reuse constantly. Pasting a pinned item is one keystroke away.
- Quit Paste, and disable its launch-at-login option so the two apps don’t both capture the clipboard.
Frequently asked questions
Is Paste 3 still available?
Paste 3 is an older major release. The current app is at version 6 and is sold through the Mac App Store and Setapp. This comparison uses the current version.
Is Maccy a free alternative to Paste?
For clipboard history, yes. Maccy is free and open source. It lacks iCloud sync, iOS apps, and shared pinboards.
Does Maccy sync between Mac and iPhone?
No. Maccy is Mac-only and keeps history locally. Paste syncs through iCloud and has iPhone and iPad apps.
Which is better for privacy?
Maccy has fewer moving parts: local storage, no account, public code. Paste stores data locally and in your private iCloud account, and supports app exclusions. Both can be configured responsibly.
The bottom line
Paste is the more complete product if you live across Apple devices. Maccy is the better tool if your clipboard needs begin and end on one Mac and you want it fast, free and inspectable. Neither is wrong; they’re built for different habits.
If Maccy sounds like your fit, you can grab it from GitHub or install it with Homebrew in under a minute. And if you’ve already tried both, what’s the one feature that made you stay with your choice?